General
Level Up Your Collection: A Collector’s Guide to WATA Video Game Grading
WATA grading verifies condition and authenticity, turning retro games into highly sought-after collectibles. Our Complete Guide to WATA Game Grading breaks down everything you need to know:
Video games aren’t just entertainment—they’re collectibles with real-world value. For retro enthusiasts and investors alike, the condition and authenticity of a game can make a huge difference in price. That’s where WATA grading comes in.
In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about WATA grading - from understanding the process to maximizing the value of your collection.
In this guide:
- What WATA grading is and why it matters.
- How WATA compares to other grading services like VGA and CGC.
- How the grading process works, including timelines and scales.
- Common red flags and controversies in the market.
- When to sell or hold graded games for maximum returns.
- How PayMore helps collectors and investors navigate both graded and ungraded collections.
- All the info you need to be equipped to make informed decisions and protect the value of your gaming investments.
Why Listen to Us?
We’ve spent years evaluating collectibles, from video games to trading cards, and we’ve watched the market evolve into a serious investment space. With expertise in grading verification, market trends, and safe transactions, we offer practical strategies for both new and experienced collectors.
What is WATA Grading?
WATA grading is a service that evaluates the condition, rarity, and authenticity of video games. It has become an essential tool for collectors who want to protect their investments, especially for high-value retro titles where every minor flaw can impact market price.
Collectors increasingly prefer graded games because grading provides transparency and verification. A WATA-graded game offers proof of condition and authenticity, which can significantly increase buyer confidence and ultimately the resale price.
High-Value WATA-Graded Games
Some of the most valuable WATA-graded games highlight the impact of rarity and condition:
- Super Mario Bros. (NES) – First print runs in near-mint condition have sold for hundreds of thousands of dollars.
- The Legend of Zelda (NES) – Rare copies in WATA 9.8 or higher are highly sought after by collectors.
- Other Iconic Titles – Limited-run games or those with cultural significance often achieve premium valuations.
These titles are prized not just for their gameplay but for their rarity and place in gaming history.
WATA vs VGA vs CGC: Which Grading Service to Choose
When evaluating games, understanding the differences between grading companies is crucial.
- WATA is known for high-value retro titles and has built a reputation for rigorous grading standards.
- VGA often handles modern or niche titles.
- CGC specializes in comic book and pop culture-adjacent games.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Grading Service
- Reputation: Does the company have a track record for accuracy?
- Turnaround Time: How long will your game be away from you?
- Cost: Grading fees vary depending on value and service speed.
- Transparency: Are grading criteria clear and consistent?
At PayMore, collectors can get professional evaluations of both graded and ungraded games, helping determine which service is most appropriate and how to maximize value.
How the WATA Grading Process Works
Submitting a game to WATA involves careful preparation. Games must be packaged securely, and submission is managed online with payment processed upfront. Once WATA receives a game, it undergoes a detailed evaluation of both packaging and game components. This includes examining the cartridge or disc, manual, and box for wear, tears, scratches, or other imperfections.
WATA Grading Scale
WATA grades games on a scale from 1.0 (Poor) to 10.0 (Mint). Key attributes assessed include:
- Packaging: Original box, shrink wrap, and artwork condition.
- Surface Quality: Scratches, marks, and discoloration on cartridge or disc.
- Manual Condition: Tears, creases, and overall wear
High-grade games (e.g., 9.8 A++) command significant premiums. Even small differences, such as a 9.6 versus 9.8, can result in thousands of dollars in price difference for high-demand titles.
Red Flags and Controversies in the Graded Game Market
While grading has professionalized the collectibles market, buyers and sellers should remain vigilant.
Common Red Flags
- Misrepresented grade or inflated condition of game.
- Counterfeit cases or labels.
- Suspicious listings without verifiable documentation.
Tip: Always verify graded games using WATA’s online resources or consult with trusted evaluators like PayMore.
Market Controversies
The industry has seen allegations of market manipulation, shill bidding, and overinflated prices. Knowledgeable collectors protect themselves by researching historical sales, tracking market trends, and working through reputable dealers.
When to Sell Graded Games vs Hold for Appreciation
Timing can make a huge difference in realizing value from your collection.
When to Sell
- When a game reaches a market peak or achieves historical sales milestones.
- When auctions or online marketplaces show consistent high demand.
When to Hold
- Rare games with increasing interest over time may appreciate further.
- Long-term strategies can pay off for investors focused on iconic titles.
- Working with PayMore, collectors can receive expert evaluations to decide the best time to sell or hold.
PayMore’s Expertise
At PayMore, collectors benefit from comprehensive assessments of both graded and ungraded games.
Experts provide:
- Clear insights into market value.
- Guidance on grading strategies.
- Assistance with buying or selling games safely.
Competitive Advantages
- Instant Cash Offers: Quick and convenient for both graded and ungraded games.
- Expert Evaluation: Ensures accuracy and maximizes value.
- Transparency and Security: Data and transactions are protected for peace of mind.
PayMore’s experience and trustworthiness make it easier for collectors and investors to navigate the complexities of the graded video game market.
WATA grading has transformed video game collecting into a professional, investment-oriented hobby. Understanding the process, evaluating the right games, and knowing when to sell or hold are critical to maximizing value.
By using trusted services like PayMore, collectors can confidently buy, sell, and protect their high-value games while avoiding pitfalls in the market.
Next Steps
Whether you’re looking to sell a rare graded game or evaluate your ungraded collection, PayMore provides expert guidance, competitive offers, and a safe, secure experience. Visit your local PayMore today and start maximizing the value of your video game collection.